|
Many users vaguely understand the
security risks, privacy invasions, and performance costs
associated with having spyware secretly and maliciously
installed on their computers. Fewer users know the many
forms spyware takes and the truly evil activities it
performs. Beyond a general sense that spyware is
uninvited, malicious software, average users know
very little about it.
Until recently, people have dismissed spyware as less
important to contend with than viruses and spam. I
believe spyware poses an even greater
threat than viruses and spam. Spyware can be as
debilitating as the nastiest of viruses. The financial
threats spyware poses are far ranging and more serious
than e-mail credit card scams (phishing), and the
privacy issues and liabilities spyware exposes are grim.
Small and medium business must understand what spyware
is and the threats spyware poses. In this, the first of
two articles, I'll explain why spyware represents
greater risk than you might have realized. In the second
article, we'll analyze spyware solutions, and pick the
best.
A spyware sampler
To simply call spyware uninvited softwareis
misleading. Spyware installed on your PC can modify the
Windows Registry and add dynamic link libraries (DLLs)
and download program files (DPFs, e.g., hostile ActiveX
or Java VM objects) to your system. Some spyware
exploits Web browsers (especially Internet Explorer) by
installing ActiveX controls, browser helper objects (BHO),
and toolbars, or by modifying browser Internet options,
including home pages, favorites lists, and
context menu items. Some spyware even alters TCP/IP
settings and hosts files.
Online spyware encyclopedia and glossaries identify
tens of thousands of malicious code considered
spyware. Some commonly encountered types of spyware
include:
- Adware
- Browser session hijackers
- Remote Administration Tools (RATs)
- Tracking agents
- Double agent spyware.
Let's take a brief look at how each of these adds to
your risk.
Not all adware is (technically)
spyware, but many experts feel that even
permission-ware is spyware when it delivers
unsolicited advertising. Common delivery methods include
unrequested browser windows (popups) and ad-sponsored
applications. There are currently nearly 800
ad-sponsored and spyware-encumbered software offerings.
This diverse group includes free versions of games
(Midnight Oil Solitaire); FTP clients (FTP
Works); e-mail clients (Eudora;
music players; Web and system utility software; and
more, often coming with a catch. The software developer
receives revenue from advertisers who display
advertising in windows or toolbar features of the
so-called freeware. Some adware (e.g.,
FlashTrack) tracks a user's Web activities and
search queries. It then sends this information to
advertising servers like Aureate and Aveo, which return
targeted advertising (commonly, popup ads) based on
keywords and phrases. As many parents know, even
seemingly benign keywords like "kittens" can expose
their children to objectionable material, including
pornography.
Browser session hijacking is a kind
of virtual world bait-and-switch. Spyware (Icoo,
WurldMedia, Xupiter Toolbar, Lop, BonziBuddy,
CoolWebSearch) redirects browser sessions and search
queries, taking users to Web sites and search engines
they didn't intend to visit. The hijacked user can be
exposed to undesirable or suspect content and
advertising. The hijackers earn referral commissions and
affiliate fees by selectively referring the user to an
e-commerce site that offers some service or product
similar to the site the user intended.
Certain Remote Administration Tools
(RATs) and keyloggers are examples of
Trojan horse spyware. As the names imply, these give
attackers administrative control, or extraordinary
eavesdropping and intercept capabilities. Acting
remotely, an attacker can intercept and log user
keystrokes, monitor application and browser activities,
and even intercept WebCam streams. BackOrifice and Sub7
are examples of attacker RATs and pose a DDoS threat.
Commercial RATs like NetObserve and
Spyagent are ostensibly sold for "legitimate tracking"
by managers, parents and suspicious spouses. The recent
and notorious
Bankhook.A is a keystroke-logging BHO delivered as
an attachment to an e-mail message. Once installed,
Bankhook tries to find banking account access data on a
PC.
Tracking agents, Web bugs,
and data miners are virtual dumpster
divers. They can monitor your Web browsing, shopping,
e-mail, and instant messaging activities, and might
gather system configuration and personal information as
well. Some tracking companies use this information to
deliver targeted advertising, but others sell or abuse
what they gather.
Alexa, a popular search toolbar, is also a data
miner. Transponder/VX2 mines e-mail addresses, browser
histories, and also scrounges data from Web forms and
configuration files.
Gator/GAIN (now Claria) claims to be
permission-ware, but anti-spyware experts claim the
client, which auto-completes forms and saves passwords,
tracks user buying habits.
Double agent spyware. Sadly, some
software that advertises as anti-spyware is itself
spyware. Users download trial- or freeware versions of
so-called security software they expect will remove
adware, only to learn that these versions are in fact
adware. Reputable anti-spyware vendors like PestPatrol
and Kephyr Labs identify
RedV EasyInstaller and
SpyBlast as spyware. If you think there's no worse
behavior than this, think again: some anti-spyware (SpyWiper)
hijacks home pages, hoping to scare unwitting users into
purchasing their product (virtual protection
racketeering!).
Assessing the spyware threat
level
In the vernacular of Homeland Security, the spyware
"threat level" is somewhere between Elevated and High.
If your business operates in a regulated environment,
place the threat level between High and Severe. Consider
these threats:
- Disclosure of sensitive or regulated
information. Spyware that tracks browser activity
doesn't distinguish between intranet or Internet
requests. Hyperlinks, browser histories, favorites
lists, and cached Web form data can contain business
records, proprietary information, trade secrets,
credit card and personal data, medical and financial
data, and account passwords, which may be abused by
the collection agent or sold to third parties.
- Users may fall victim to felony-class criminal
acts. Keyloggers reveal sensitive personal and
company information, including passwords, credit card
and financial information, and potentially
embarrassing personal information. An intercepted
WebCam stream might reveal embarrassing activities.
The opportunities spyware creates for fraud, identity
theft, and personal or business-targeted extortion
should be taken very seriously.
- Loss of productivity. Spyware steals CPU
and bandwidth while it is running. Spyware isn't the
best-written software in the world and commonly causes
system instability and the dreaded blue screen of
death . Spyware removal is often non-trivial,
disruptive, or destructive. Some spyware remains on
your system after you have uninstalled the freeware,
and some might reinstall itself if not entirely
removed. If spyware extensively infests your network,
you can spend as much time repairing and remediating
systems as you would following a virus incident or
backdoor attack.
-
System and Network Intrusions. The
information collected by trackers, miners and RATs is
gold for any attacker engaged in an
information gathering expedition, which is the
preparation stage in a targeted attack. Hosts
identified in hyperlinks and system configuration
information help attackers map networks and services.
Some organizations (unwisely) transmit account names
and passwords in plain text across intranet links.
Need I say more?
- Tarnished brand image and loss of business.
Your company can be affected by spyware, even if every
computer you operate is spyware-free. If hijacking
spyware victimizes your company, you'll lose sales
opportunities when users are redirected away from your
site, to a competitor. Hijacking spyware has also been
used to scam companies who pay fees for advertising
referrals. A disreputable ad company, hired to drive
traffic to e-merchant sites of its patrons, might
embed spyware in a "must have" toolbar. The spyware
replaces the user's default search engine, and sends
users to pages of its patrons, even when they are not
a suitable match. The patrons pay for these contrived
referrals but often do not derive the expected revenue
per click-through.
- Exposure to litigation. Some employees
may react strongly to the delivery of objectionable,
especially sexually explicit advertising, and may
respond by claiming sexual harassment. Whether the
claim has merit or not, the publicity, court time,
expense, and loss of credibility can be more than your
company wants to deal with.
I hope I've convinced you that spyware is a serious
threat. In my next article, I'll describe methods to
identify and remediate systems infected with spyware,
and methods to provide ongoing protection. I'll also
recommend spyware removal and blocking software to
assist you in these processes, along with some emerging
"best antispyware" practices. See you next week. |